25 Trina Robbins Raina Telgemeier
24 Rumiko Takahashi Barbara Kesel
23 Jo Chen Jen Van Meter
22 Emily Carroll Marguerite Bennett (10)
21 Colleen Coover (5) Colleen Doran
20 Wendy Pini Jo Duffy
19 Jillian Tamaki Kate Leth
18 Ming Doyle Rumiko Takahashi
17 Faith Erin Hicks Allie Brosh
16 Stephanie Hans Lynda Barry
15 Marie Severin Hiromu Arakawa
14 Kate Beaton Becky Cloonan
13 Annie Wu Emily Carroll
12 Ramona Fradon Devin Grayson (4)
11 Babs Tarr Marjorie Liu (3)
10 Pia Guerra Noelle Stevenson
9 Amy Reeder Kathryn Immonen (5)
8 Nicola Scott Marjane Satrapi
7 Colleen Doran Ann Nocenti (2)
6 Sara Pichelli (1) Alison Bechdel
5 Emma Rios Kate Beaton
4 Jill Thompson (3) Louise Simonson (1)
3 Becky Cloonan G. Willow Wilson (8)
2 Amanda Conner Gail Simone (7)
1 Fiona Staples Kelly Sue DeConnick
Brian Cronin and Kelly Thompson really outdid themselves with this list!
Here is who I voted for :
- Louise Simonson
2. Ann Nocenti
3. Marjorie Liu
4. Devin Grayson
5. Kathryn Immonen
6. Kim Yale
7. Gail Simone
8. G. Willow Wilson
9. Kelly Thompson
10. Marguerite Bennett
- Sara Pichelli
2. Rachel Dodson
3. Jill Thompson
4. June Brigman
5. Colleen Coover
6. Ariela Kristantina
7. Altri Firmansyah
8. Yasmine Putri
9. Alisson Borges
10. Sonia Oback
How did I forget Jo Duffy!?!
Not too many people who made both lists, I thought with all of the comments, that there would be more creators on the same lists.
Rumiko Takahashi (A24 W18)
Emily Carroll (A22 W13)
Kate Beaton (A14 W5)
Colleen Doran (A7 W21)
Four is still pretty impressive!
I’m pretty impress with myself for getting so many writers on my list, making it to the big list. I had Kelly Sue DeConnick but replaced her with Marguerite Bennett. I should have taken Kelly Thompson off the list and kept both of the other two but since Kelly worked on the list, I thought that wouldn’t be proper. PLUS, if Kelly did make the list, I wanted to be within the number that did vote for her but that clearly didn’t work out. I wonder if she got any votes or was I the main one.
I am still pretty embarrass that I left off Jo Duffy, she is such a great writer! She could have been ranked 19 if I had done it right!
Really surprised that DeConnick beat out Simone but I’m also surprised that Louise Simonson didn’t make it to the Top Three.
I thought that I would have had more lady artists make the big list but I also don’t really know any of them either, in terms of all popular they are and such. I believe that Sonia Oback may be like Rachel Dodson and doesn’t do pencils but mainly inks. I could be wrong on that.
Looking over the list, I’m not sure if any of these pairings have worked together. Some would make pretty good creative teams, that’s for sure!